Skip to main content
Society & Culture

Large language models can predict the results of social science experiments.

| Source: Nature

There is growing interest in how large language models (LLMs) can advance social and behavioural science 1-5 . Previous work has assessed LLMs' ability to predict survey responses 6-9 , but less is known about whether they can predict the outcomes of social science experiments 10 , particularly those absent from training data. Here we built an archive of 70 preregistered, nationally representative survey experiments in the USA involving 469 experimental effects and 119,330 participants. We

There is growing interest in how large language models (LLMs) can advance social and behavioural science 1-5 . Previous work has assessed LLMs' ability to predict survey responses 6-9 , but less is known about whether they can predict the outcomes of social science experiments 10 , particularly those absent from training data. Here we built an archive of 70 preregistered, nationally representative survey experiments in the USA involving 469 experimental effects and 119,330 participants. We prompted an LLM to simulate how representative samples from American individuals would respond to experimental stimuli, and then we inferred treatment effects by comparing simulated responses across conditions. Predictions derived from GPT-4, whose training-data cutoff predated the publication of many studies in our archive, were strongly correlated with actual treatment effects, achieving accuracy similar to pooled human forecasts. Correlations remained high for studies not published or publicly posted by the model's training-data cutoff date and for predictions from prominent open-weight models. Despite high correlations, predictions systematically overestimated effect sizes. In a secondary archive of 15 megastudies featuring 606 effects, correlations were lower but comparable to those of pooled expert forecasters. To assess implications for scientific practice, we surveyed 460 social scientists about probable uses and perceived risks and used our archives to assess several applications (pilot testing, intervention selection, identifying effects needing replication) and risks (bias, misuse). Together, these results indicate that LLMs can augment experimental methods in science and practice while raising important considerations for responsible use.

Read the original source →

Related Stories

Society & Culture

Global greenhouse gas cobenefits of US irrigated agriculture.

Land use and land conversion for agriculture contribute nearly a quarter of global greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, making the sector a key priority for emissions reductions. Crop yields are one factor that modulate agricultural land demand, with, all else equal, global land use change increasing with yield declines and decreasing with yield gains. Therefore, agricultural practices drive both direct, on-farm emissions, and indirect land use change emissions through yield effects. Here, we couple

Continue reading
Society & Culture

Cerebellar microcircuits enable robust evidence-based decisions through cortico-cerebellar coupling.

The cerebellum is increasingly implicated in perceptual decision-making, yet it remains unclear how the cerebellar cortex can support sparse evidence accumulation over behavioral time scales without assuming cortical-style dense local excitatory recurrence. We present a biologically constrained modeling framework showing that cerebellar microcircuits can implement graded accumulation and competition in the absence of such recurrence. In our model, type-II Purkinje-neuron excitability generates f

Continue reading
Society & Culture

Loss of neuronal population organization links pathology to behavior in a model of Alzheimer's disease.

Alzheimer's disease and related dementias are typically described at two levels: the accumulation of molecular pathology and the emergence of cognitive impairment. Understanding the relationship between pathology, often studied in animal models, and human cognition will require measurements spanning intermediate scales, including single neurons, neuronal populations, and distributed networks. Here we combine longitudinal measurements of behavior and neuronal population activity with fluid and hi

Continue reading
Society & Culture

Deconstruction of lysergic acid diethylamide.

Of the classic psychedelics, lysergic acid diethylamide (LSD) is perhaps the best-known, but its complex chemical architecture has limited synthetic investigations aimed at generating analogues with improved safety and efficacy profiles. Here, we systematically deconstruct the tetracyclic ergoline core of LSD to create 9 simplified ergoline analogues (i.e., ergologs) and evaluate them in pharmacological assays relevant to 5-HT2A, 5-HT2B, and 5-HT2C receptor function. Our work revealed the key mo

Continue reading
Society & Culture

A role for self-regulatory control in the absence of ingroup preference.

One of psychology's most ubiquitous findings is that of robust ingroup preference, an explicitly stated human preference for the groups to which we belong. The advent of implicit measures of social cognition introduced a paradoxical result: Compared to members of higher-status groups, members of lower-status groups often show no implicit ingroup preference, sometimes even showing outgroup preference, a result rarely observed on explicit measures. Prevailing theories have provided macro-level acc

Continue reading